- All Topics »
- Politics and Social Issues »
- Charities »
- Advancement of Religion
Does Charity come with a Price?
81There are many charities all over the world that are famous for going far out of their way to help the disenfranchised, the down-trodden, the unfortunate, the ignorant, the innocent, the poor, the oppressed, the starving, the victims of war. These Charitable Organizations are seen as largely helpful and simply trying to bring hope and salvation to these affected people. Their Charity knows no bounds and seems to have no hidden conditions attached. Or at least, that’s what they want you to believe.
What? I hear you cry. There’s another side to this story? Another angle we haven’t been privy to? Ask yourself this question – is all charity unconditional? In other words, is it given with no conditions attached? That depends on the charity and its religious intent. Okay, some Charities are not religious, there are Foundations and they just give Charity where it is needed. This is not an attack on the religious. The truth is, some charity is given to the less well off based on religious reasons and less on need. Why?
Because some charitable volunteers give out loaves of bread with the one hand and give out bibles with the other. So is that right? Charities giving out charity but trying to religiously convert and recruit the very people the Charity is helping. Imagine being there listening to a priest asking a poor woman why does she pray? Asking her who does she pray to? What deity exactly is that? And don’t they know there is only one GOD? Some charities want to save, but at a price. They seem to want the person’s soul too. But surely when a charity is helping the underprivileged, it is better and more morally acceptable not to take advantage of their position? Or better not to take advantage of their ignorance. Is this kind of charity just a way of spreading a gospel? Making a religious “sale”? A conversion. Do the poor need someone giving them faith? Aren’t some people entitled to be Atheists if they want to? Do Atheists get charity? What about Agnostics? Do donations apply to them too?
Or is being charitable and giving aid a way to “own” them, “control” them. A loaf of bread and then a sermon? Didn’t Cecil Rhodes all those years ago march into Rhodesia (later named after him in his honour), a once backward country which he supposedly pitied and gave charity and food with one hand and bibles with the other? The same Cecil Rhodes who then went on to possess and own the people religiously and the country materially, and wasn’t he the one involved in one of the richest firms in the world – the De Beers Diamond company? Wasn’t that charity really just a kind of Imperialism? A way of colonizing people? And isn’t most charity just doing the same? Religious imperialism continuing its way through the poor countries of the world. Is it fair or appropriate to use charity as a means to gains? Just why are charities so intent on converting people? Is the service of the poor in the end just a scam? How should that affect the way we donate to Charity?
Thankfully there are honest charities who are not really
interested in giving out bibles, they are only interested in Social Justice for the people they are
helping. An example would be a Foundation.
Why not just give charity and leave it at that? Since when did faith have to enter this equation? Since some Aid groups belong to some faith, is that a disadvantage? The idea of bread and bibles being given to the weak and then proselytizing to them in their time of need, however, seems incompatible with our definition of Charity or Help for that matter. Is there a kind of colonialism happening by stealth in some charities? Haven’t there been problems with some faiths poaching some believers in other faiths? By implying that they were worshiping a false God? Where are we going with this? Isn’t this treading on very dangerous ground?
Some charities admit that they do give out Bibles and other
religious material. But some others just give charity. Some charities stand for
Social Justice and seek to make the world a fairer and more just place. Some
have admirable records. Some however, insist on handing out Bibles and telling where the charity comes from. The author and broadcaster Mathew Paris famously once
said “Africa needs God”, which is a surprising comment from a man who is an Atheist.
Didn’t the Vatican get into trouble in Africa by telling
people that for religious Catholic reasons, they should not wear Condoms as they were unholy and against
God’s wishes? And this is a country
with the highest Aids rate on Earth! Do some people in Africa need that kind of charity or help, even though it runs counter to all common sense and medical opinion? Are Religious Charitable Organizations really being helpful to people like this or
are the charities in question just trying to see how stupid some people are? Is this tantamount to rubbing people's noses in it? It sounds like someone is having a laugh....
Also of concern is the reluctance of some charities to share
their charity with other charities where there is a separate religious belief
system. In a place where a tragedy has occurred and
help is needed, and people may wish to donate to a good cause. Yet
people have to be sensitive to people’s existing religious belief and culture.
There doesn’t seem to be much of an appetite for international agreement in
this sphere. This is surprising – given the issues we are all dealing with.
This could be revised as charities could make an enormous difference where
there are compatible aims between
charities, i.e. – a desire to help others unconditionally,
without the normal one-up-manship and competition. It does seem like a form of one-up-manship sometimes. To
be arguing these points here when people’s lives hang in the balance seems like
sheer lunacy. The Poverty and misery that people face is what needs attention, not
some religious belief system or archaic argument.There is a clear chicken and egg scenario here. The Egg, the symbol of life clearly comes first.
The business of giving charity ought to be a simple one, yet it is a complex one.
It is simple, but it is certain people who have complicated it.
It is sometimes seen as conditional giving and in some ways religiously interfering with some other faiths, hence reluctance to share charity amongst groups. Secularism plays its part in charity too. It seems that there is an answer to the question – when is a charity not just a charity? When it is also sometimes a faith based group or church. Giving out bread and bibles is not always a good idea. When a charity tells a starving man he cannot have the bread without the bible and a sermon, then there is something seriously wrong. Meanwhile the world has people in dire need of help and assistance from people like us who thankfully are willing to share what they have with others out of the decency of their hearts. Now if the charities will just let that happen, that will be really nice!
Why not join the growing community of writers here on Hub Pages? Register and join for free, and even use your Hubs to generate income for yourself.
![]() | Amazon Price: $46.61 List Price: $52.00 |
Amazon Price: $2.64 List Price: $14.95 | |
![]() | Amazon Price: $8.73 List Price: $26.95 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $24.99 List Price: $30.00 |
You might also check out...
- Burma at a crossroads in 2010
Burma is one of the most troubled, most divided countries in the world. It has a history of almost permanent war for many centuries, interspersed with brief periods of calm and peace. The various tribes of the Mon, the Karen, the Kachins, the Shan...
CommentsLoading...
I agree with Darski a very powerful hub, jeeez I complain about being skint but when I saw that photo of the whole family on the bicycle it made me feel a very rich man, deff we should all be greatful for what we have. Brilliant hub, rated up xox
What a great hub Cheeky Girl! You've certainly hit the nail on the head with this one. Personally, I only give to non religious charities for this very reason. Taking advantage of people in need by foisting religious doctrine on them is sick. It reminds me of when I was a young single mum. I was always getting the Jehovahs and Mormons knocking at my door trying to convert me, lol. They saw me as vulnerable and tried to capitalise on that. Little did they know!
I give to religious charities and pray the do the right thing.Very good hub.
Hy Cassy, Omg, the forum looks amazing. Did you tell Art? I love this hub! I am glad you wrote this. The kid with the vulture waiting behind is kind of scary. I totally think charity comes with a price, but only if you let it come with the price. Powerful stuff here. You are wasted in finance. You should be working in the Charitable Giving or Campaign business areas, you have the attitude and passion for it. :)
Love! XXXOXXX
Hi cheeky girl, first of all thanks for leaving comments on my hubs and i m sorry i havent been active here. About this hub well there is no such thing as free lunch. Everything has to be paid back. SO atleast people in India are not convinced that the Christian churches or charities are really doing any charity here because they always try to convert ( again pls donot take offence on this truth.. esp Christians of India). Yes what you said in your hub is right. Even when countries help each other they would expect their vote in UNO or some other things. So babe nothing is free in this world.
Hey, as we know it in India, charity is just a form of business, unholy that too!! One collects millions in donations and distribute a few blankets to the poor or few strings of old clothes and enjoy the rest of the big figure!! Yes, taking good videography, calling in the media during the event or getting a celebrity to the occasion is only a part of the game!! Charity is the most unholy business in the world!!
This is a very good hub. All comments are valid. I do love that bicycle. It looks like 9 are getting a "free ride". Thanks!
right. guess it's not really charity. It5hink in India they call it a "rice conversion", because the person becomes a Christian to get some food.
One really has to watch religious fanatics of all types.
Yer Forum is cool Cassy but tis not like wat I have planned, I am currently designing it and wen I get it off the ground in 3 weeks I want you and Cathy to run it with me, jeez I have the best name for it as well to attract traffic but all will be revealed but I want you and Cathy in it with me, yer my girls ; ) xox
you write with passion and with care. I like the way you think! it is imperialism to some extent! my twin sis said I read you as you are a good writer hehe, My cheeky, Thank you BTW, HUGS!
This is an interesting Hub. As far as we know, the 'big name' (in the UK) Christian charities like Christian Aid give on the basis of need. However, when giving to any charity we think it is important to do some research and find out where your money really is going. Some charities are not well run and a lot of money goes to admin costs, others really don't do what you think the might with the money. There is a lot of need in the world, and a limited amount of money to give away - make sure you put your money where it is most needed.
Wow!...I have always researched a charity well before giving my money to them. I would just as soon give a beggar on the street the money than give it to an organization....I know all to well that most of the dollar I give that big charity goes to the CEO's or for overhead. More people need to be aware of this but they don't bother.
I don't see the father of that small nation which moves for a family outing on a single bike. Must be trying some where else to increase further of a new family. Gr8 Indian!
Enjoyed your hub. It is a good thing to be careful when it involves charities to make sure your charity is doing what it was intended to do. God Bless You.
It's always a difficult thing when it comes to many of these charities, which one really has the ability to get to the people. If I'm going to donate I try and do my due dilligence to see that the charity goes directly to the recipient, rather than being funneled through governments—which is never effective, ESPECIALLY in under developed or poorer countries.
Great, and albeit sad, but informative hub Cheeky Girl.
Charities are not like they used to be and it is ashame, I honestly started contacting charities when we needed a helping hand and they closed the doors. I was in utter shock all of that money and they could not assist? Now I only give to those who are truly charitable organizations and will truly help the people, but of course we know those are far and few in between. :)
Wow this is a great hub, and a great point of view you have taken, I really enjoyed reading this. I love how you said "Thankfully there are honest charities who are not really interested in giving out bibles, they are only interested in Social Justice for the people they are helping." this hub is so powerful.
Wow! it is amazing how some people have to live in this world! The photos are amazing you chose to go with the hub! great work Cheeky Girl!
Powerful hub that is sad but so true. Man will not find the true meaning of religion or spirituality until we can give charity to a person in need without having the desire of changing who they are or their beliefs.
And what is even sadder now a days is that you can be a contributor to these charities for years, however if something happens and you need help; you will not receive a penny nor any sympathy for your situation. Thumbs up!
Very well said and written, moi friend! :) What I loved so much bout it is you've put your heart on it. Damn, you could be a great leader! And editorials from some newspapers have no say with what I've read ;)
Yup people take advantage of charities nowadays overshadowing the real motive of charities with their own motives.
This is bravo!
Hi Cheeky Girl, you really made me think a lot about this thought provoking hub that you wrote. And so much of you in here too - your passion and your beliefs. It gave me a warm feeling that a lot of people show they care by giving to charities.
In my life right now, I also started "giving" to the people around me, people that I know who need help too. Even in the preschool that I run, some of the staff are struggling balancing financial needs and it is still my utmost desire to be able to give more, and yet, we still find that a challenge.
Howdy Cheeky Girl. I came back for another read. Reading it again- the chords struck me in the way I've been seeing things lately. More and more I see the foundation of religions ignored. The "religious" do emphasize their "Book". Their way. Read this- this is THE WAY!
Every religion has a form of the Golden Rule. Every religion! Yet- it is THIS rule that is not promoted by "Faiths". I advocate any faith that practices the Golden Rule above all else. Thanks
Really thought provoking hub
I loved the additional input Cheeky Girl. :) I have to rush now for work so when I can, I'll drop you an email. Thanks!
Hi Cheeky, this is very well written and powerfull hub. I am afraid historically many groups have used charities as way of progressing their ideologies. This hub does a very good job to highlighting the issues we should all be aware of.
I no longer give to charities I haven't educated myself on........... most of my donations go to local charities where I can actually see them at work.
Great Hub!
Kaie
Great job CG, some people are just twisted by fossilized prattle and platitudes. I know of some really great local charities here that just give it out with no judgments or preaching or prejudice.
Great Hub, I relate to your views and myself have experienced a life filled with charity work, in fact today I'm coordinating Miracle Mountain, It's a food, school supplies and personal needs drive and awareness program I do once every quarter. Lovely Hub, Thank and Peace ;)
You have touched on some very important truths here! We should all give/help/love unconditionally. I'm certainly not perfect & should do more. Whenever able I volunteer & give to whoever is reaching the hurting in a meaningful way. (Church & NON Church related - doesnt matter to me as long as 80-90% is direct assistance) Giving is a beautiful thing for all to be involved in.
[Two of my favorites invisible children & Mercy Corps]
This is an interesting hub and I would be really interested to have a list of some of these Christian charities that will only give aid to people who will agree to certain things as I would not want to fund something like that. I know a lot of Christian charities give out religious materials but I never knew that some made the giving conditional on the acceptance of certain things before giving the aid. I would be really interested to know the names
A very thoughtful hub. Thank you for your insight into this issue, and thank you for sharing it with us! Service and charity should indeed be an unconditional act, given from the heart.
This is a very interesting article. I hate when people give (whether it is an organization or individual) just because they want something in return.
Bravo Cheeky Girl, love this hub! So Well True, post it everywhere!! Call it out!!









































Darlene Sabella 2 years ago
Wow, this is such a powerful hub and I agree with you. We all need to help in some way, and for me I, when I was younger, always was involved in local needs, local people. Even a neighbor, or friend in need. Whilst all our funds leave the country, we have so much need here. Thanks for a fantastic hub my friend...